<table><tr><th>From:</th><th>Noam Chomsky</th></tr><tr><td>Sent:</td><td>Sunday, October 29, 2017 6:18 PM</td></tr><tr><td>To:</td><td>Deborah Pechet Quinan</td></tr><tr><td>Cc:</td><td>Valeria Chomsky</td></tr><tr><td>Subject:</td><td>Fwd: trust</td></tr></table>

Thanks for the informative letter. I would appr=ciate it if you could craft a letter, as you suggest, which I will use to =ontact all three children.

Thanks

Noam

- Header: "Forwarded message"
- From: [name and email redacted] (mailto link present)
- Date: "Fri, Oct 27, 201= at 4:56 PM" (year partly obscured)
- Subject: "Fwd: trust"
- To: [recipient name/email redacted]
- Cc: multiple recipients (names/emails largely blacked out; at least one mailto link visible)
- Many black redaction bars covering names and email addresses throughout the header lines

=br>

Dear Noam,

You are waiting for me to provide guidance as to how you can regain co=trol of the trust funds. My plan is to prepare a memo for you outlin=ng your options in light of the trust terms. I anticipate being able=to spend some time on this over the weekend, along with reviewing the drafts of your estate planning documents. O=ce I have sent the memo to you we can discuss your thoughts and we can the= respond to Max. Unfortunately this is a difficult situation, not simple a=d straightforward, because of the terms of the trust and fiduciary law applicable to trusts. Please see my e=ail of 10/17 for an explanation of some of the issues.

In some situations a trust is drafted so that you would have the right=to remove and replace the trustee, and in doing so perhaps find a trustee =hat would not inquire so diligently as to your personal financial circumst=nces before making a principal distribution to you. In this regard, please refer to my email of 10/=7 where I summarize the trustee removal, resignation and appointment provi=ions. The trustees can both resign at any time. They appoint successors su=ject to your approval. If they agree to resign you can find a new independent trustee whom they can appoint. If=not, you can remove them but only with the approval of a majority of your =hildren. Do you think your daughters would agree to remove Max and Harry? =f so you could then appoint a successor. You would need to find an independent trustee. I can help you craft = letter to your daughters if you think they might agree to do this. <=div>

My one additional thought right now that I need to review more closely=is that Harry, not being the independent trustee, should not have a say in=the distribution decision. If there is nothing in the trust to contradict =his interpretation (I need to review the trust again) then Max alone has the power. However this would likely n=t change the analysis that Max believes he needs to go through since he is=accountable to all beneficiaries. He believes he needs some level of=financial information from you but in my view that does not need to be detailed. I can discuss with him wh=t level of detail would satisfy him; however, if my understanding is corre=t that you do not wish to provide him with any backup for his distribution=decision, then we should evaluate the removal option and any other strategies I may be able to come up with.Q=A0

Unfortunately this is not a simple situation and I will do my best to =utline some additional options for you. In the meantime please let me know=your thoughts regarding the above. I am available for a call as well= at your convenience.

Best,
Deborah

=ent from my iPhone. Please excuse brevity and typos.

Begin forwarded message:

| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Header | Begin forwarded message: |
| From | [redacted] <mailto:[redacted]> |
| Date | October 27, 2017 at 1:21:50 PM EDT |
| To | [redacted] <mailto:[redacted]> |
| Cc | [redacted]; [redacted] <mailto:[redacted]> |
| Subject | Re: trust |
| Opening line visible | Hello [redacted] - |

Hello Noam -

I'm afraid I cannot send the money you have requested without furt=er discussion with you and I also feel I cannot have such a discussion wit= you without Deborah's knowledge and participation, as she is your att=rney. Please also note that any distributions from the trusts would also involve Harry, who is the co-trustee of the tru=ts.

As you will see, I have again copied Deborah on my reply. I will=be glad to follow up with a meeting or a call when I return, next week.

Thanks,

Max

Sent from my Verizo=, Samsung Galaxy smartphone

The image shows an email header:

*   **From:** Noam Chomsky
*   **Date:** 10/27/17 5:14 PM (GMT+00:00)
*   **To:** Max Kohlenberg
*   **Subject:** Fwd: trust

There seems to be some confusion. I was responding to your lette= of Oct. 16, in which you said you would be getting back to me the next da=. That was the last time we were in touch. Since I didn't =ear from you, I wrote again, last night.

My letter to you explained the reasons for my request for a distributi=n from the marital trust. To repeat, "I would like to get on wi=h my life and work without delay. I've worked hard for 70 years,=put away a substantial sum of money. I surely have the right to access it."

I don't see what further explanation is necessary, or why it is ne=essary to bring Deborah into this. I could add that as I approach 90= having worked hard for 70 years and put away a substantial sum of money, = not only have the right to some peace and tranquillity to go on with my life and work, but also to do so without fac=ng an inquisition.

If you are unable to transfer the money this week , could you please detail=for me the reasons behind the decision.

The image is an email.

*   **Sender**: Max Kohlenberg
*   **Date**: Wed, Oct 25, 2017 at 10:55 PM
*   **Subject**: RE: trust
*   **To**: Noam Chomsky
*   **Cc**: Deborah Pechet Quinan

Good morning (from S=otland) Noam —

=/span>

When we were last in=touch on this I replied with a cc to Deborah (who I have copied agai= here) and I understood that you, she and Valeria had discussed my need (as trustee) to know something more about the background for this =equest and your anticipated needs going forward. Deborah got back to=me and indicated that the call she and I had tentatively scheduled was bei=g cancelled.

=/span>

If you would like me=to reschedule a call with Deborah, or a meeting, I’d be glad to do=that. I’ll be back on
Tuesday.
=/span>
My best,</=>
=/span>
Max
=/span>

From: Noam Chomsky=[mailto: <mailto
Sent: Thursday, October 26, 2017 6:43 AM
To: Max Kohlenberg
Subject: Re: trust

I didn't hear from you about this, and would lik= to what is happening in this matter. I would like to get on with my=life and work without delay. I've worked hard for 70 years, put =way a substantial sum of money. I surely have the right to access it. Could you let me know where this stands.a>

Noam

On Mon, Oct 16, 2017 at 9:55 PM, Max Kohlenberg <=a href="mailto:
target="_blank' wrote:

Thanks for the quick reply Noam. I will get ba=k to you tomorrow.

Max

S=nt from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone

| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Header marker | "------- Original message -------" |
| From | Name shown in image — withheld; email address redacted |
| Date | 10/16/17 9:14 PM (GMT-05:00) |
| To | Name shown in image — withheld; email address redacted |
| Subject | Re: trust |
| Surrounding text (provided) | "Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone" ; "I meant $500,000." |

I meant $500,000.

4

Noam

On Mon, Oct 16, 2017 at 9:00 PM, Max Kohlenberg <=a href="mailt

target="_blank">

wrote:

Forgive me for asking Noam, but did you mean $500,00=, or $50,000?

Thanks,

Max

S=nt from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone

- Type: Email header (labeled "Original message")
- From: [Sender name and email redacted] (black bars over parts of the From line)
- To: [Recipient name and email redacted] (black bars over parts of the To line)
- Date: 10/16/17 6:44 PM (GMT-05:00)
- Subject: trust
- Footer/device note: "Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone" (appears near top, rendered as "S=nt from...")

Dear Max,<=u>

=/span>

I would like to ask =or a distribution from one of the marital trusts, for $500,000, to deal wi=h current expenses of mine.

=/span>

Thanks for your cons=deration

=/span>

Noam</=pan>

=/span>

=/span>

NOTICE: This email with its attachments, if any, is intended solely for per=itted use by authorized recipients. If you are not an authorized recipient=of this email, your retention, transmission, disclosure, or use of this em=il is prohibited. If you received this email in error, please notify the sender and delete this email and it= attachments from your devices and systems.