<table><tr><th>From:</th><th>Lawrence Krauss</th></tr><tr><td>Sent:</td><td>Thursday, December 14, 2017 10:O0 PM</td></tr><tr><td>To:</td><td>Peter Aldhous</td></tr><tr><td>Cc:</td><td>Lawrence Krauss</td></tr><tr><td>Subject:</td><td>Item 4/your query</td></tr></table>

I =on't have that info.. I think she called me at the time, =nd I have no idea when it was, but it was some time.. some months =aybe, after the conference. In any case, I don't see why that is =mportant or relevant at this point. It is obvious from Robin's =eport that the episode she was referring to is the same one you were =eferring to.. same conference.. same location.. and her report =emonstrates that the actual events differ from those reported in your =tem..

In all =he cases where external validation was possible the claims you listed =ave been shown to not be factual and the facts don't validate =he thesis of your investigation. There is no history or trend =ere, and organizations are not trying to gloss over or ignore =ccusations. I know that you have devoted time to this, but as =ome with science background you know that research doesn't =lways produce results that meet initial expectations but can still be =seful. Perhaps there is a useful story out there about how =requently false allegations do occur in certain communities, how =nstitutions get caught up with having to deal with and investigate =hem, often negatively impacting on the rights of the accused, and how =he media can get sucked in to enabling this.

Right now I am really =rying to work hard to do good things. Just had a Skype session with =tudents in Bangladesh who are interested in science. It is =mportant to help them. I really want to get on with the =ork I do that is useful.

Lawrence M. Krauss
Director, The Origins Project at ASU
Co-Director, Cosmology Initiative
Foundation Professor
School of Earth & Space Exploration and Physics Department Arizona State University, P.O. Box 871404, Tempe, AZ 85287-1404
Research Office: 
Assistant (Jessica): 
Origins Office (Cynthia): 
<mailto:  > &nbsp;
origins.asu.edu | 

</span>

On Dec 14, 2017, at 12:39 PM, Peter Aldhous  wrote:

I =ad a long chat with Robin yesterday. The one thing she wasn't able to provide was more information about the blog post -- which we were not aware of. Obviously, if we can locate a post that was not disclosed to us previously, that's important.

Did Robin happen to send you a link, or provide any more details about it that would help us find it? And can you remember when Robin told you about this?

I guess the ideal situation would be if Robin had =mailed you at the time and sent a link to the post, outlining her concerns about its veracity. Are you able to look through your archives and see if you have that?

## On 12/13/17 12:28 PM, Lawrence Krauss wrote:

Please confirm receipt. Thanks.

LMK

On Dec 13, 2017, at 12:58 AM, Lawrence =rauss
<mailto: wrote:

FYI: Today, as my head cleared =nd I could relax a bit, I reviewed your original email to me and it hit me that item 4 might relate to an episode that Robin Cornwell had alerted me to some years ago. At the time Robin was Exec. Director =f the Richard Dawkins Foundation, and was with me and some others from the Foundation when a young woman from a conference I was speaking at (which I knew was in the midwest but had forgotten was in Iowa) and asked to join our table at a bar. She, =nbsp;(the young woman) invited me to go to a hot tub and I =eclined. Robin then called me sometime later, very upset, =o say that this individual had written a blog accusing me of harassment, distorting the episode, and letting me know she was an eyewitness if I ever needed one. =nbsp;l never looked at the student's blog, and forgot =bout it. I remembered Robin's call then today =s I thought about your email. I contacted Robin earlier this evening. Here is my email to her attaching your original description, and her response, which she has given me permission to send to you..

LMK

Begin forwarded message:

From: Lawrence Krauss

Subject: buzzfeed allegation

Date: December 12, 2017 at 10:49:25 PM MST

To: robin cornwell

Robin:

Here is the allegation from =uzzfeed which I remembered today seemed to fit to a false blog story which you had related to me and warned me about based on our experience at a conference in Iowa when you were exec. director of the Dawkins Foundation. I would =reatly appreciate it if you could write to me about your eyewitness experience at that event. =nbsp;

## On 12/13/17 12:28 PM, Lawrence Krauss wrote: (cont.)

Thanks very much for your =ttention in this matter.

Lawrence

Incident 4:

You met a student from =nother university, an atheist activist, in March 2008 at the American =theists Convention in Minneapolis. She wanted to expand the atheist =roup she ran at the midwestern university she was attending, and hoped =o convince you to come and speak. You initially seemed enthusiastic. =/span> During the convention, =ttendees including you and Richard Dawkins went for dinner with the =tudent and volunteers for Dawkins' foundation. Afterwards, the =tudent invited you to join the volunteers for a drink. You asked her to come =et you in your hotel room. She was wary of your intentions, and so =rought a male friend with her. Opening the door to find them both =here, you informed her you had decided not to go. You met this student =gain at the American Atheists =onvention in Des Moines, Iowa, in April 2011. You pulled over a =hair for her in the bar, and then started running your hand up her leg =nder the table. She tried to shift her =ody away from you, and you persisted in putting your hand on her leg. =he crossed her legs, and you kept trying. Then she turned her entire =ody away.

Lawrence M. Krauss
Director, The Origins Project at ASU
Co-Director, Cosmology Initiative
Foundation =rofessor
School of Earth & Space Exploration and Physics Department
Arizona State =niversity, P.O. Box 871404, Tempe, AZ =5287-1404
Research Office Assistant (Jessica)
Origins Office (Cynt
krauss@asu.edu
origins.asu.edu

## On 12/13/17 12:28 PM, Lawrence Krauss wrote: (cont.)

<image002.png>

- Begin forwarded message:
- From: [REDACTED] (sender name partially visible; email address redacted)
- Subject: Oy!
- Date: December 12, 2017 at 11:09:50 PM MST
- To: [REDACTED] <mailto:[REDACTED]>
- Message snippet: "Dear =awrence"
- Visible artifacts: "=</b>" / "=/b>" HTML-like fragments around labels; several fields blacked out.

Dear =awrence,

You are correct, I remember the incident at the bar with the student organizer very well. I was the one responsible for persuading you to come to Iowa for the conference - but had promised I would buy you a scotch if you agreed to be part of the program. We met at the bar at the hotel =nd Michael and Suzy from RDF joined us at first. Slowly some other people drifted in and joined us - one of them was the head of the Secular Student Alliance - and then a couple of students associated with that organization joined our table. I think they were delighted to get the opportunity to meet you The women you mention, she sat across from you and was very chatty with you - very friendly. =nbsp;She was trying to convince you to come up to go to the hot tub and you replied that you did not pack any swim trunks, and she replied that you didn't need any - a towel would be just fine.

I had the sense you were a =ittle uncomfortable and both trying to be nice but also trying to change the topic. At one point, you leaned over and asked me 'Is she hitting on me?" I replied that indeed she was =rom my perspective. Then a few minutes later =ou said she was rubbing her leg against yours. By then you were obviously not =omfortable - and she continued to invite you to the hot tub. You continued to decline - and it =as by that time becoming annoying. She finally realized that you were not about to go with her, so she left (the other students had left by then as well). After she left you =aid again how she was rubbing up against you with her feet - and you jokingly (or maybe half-jokingly) said to me something along the lines of keeping you safe from her during the conference.

It might have been a year later = I saw a post by that student organizer who had hit on you at the bar and she had written that you had been the one who was hitting on her and tried to turn it into you being offensive. I alerted you to her accusation, and =hile nothing came of it at that time, I had said that if you needed a witness to that evening I would certainly step up as her accusations were completely false. I personally =hink she was offended that you declined her offer to go to the hot-tub.

I think the reason why that evening stands out so well in my mind is that her flirting with you was so blatant and you were so uncomfortable with the situation. =nbsp;If there is a need, you can provide the person from Buzzfeed with my contact information. This week is extremely busy with all day meetings the rest of the week, but I will make the time to clarify the truth.

Please give my best to Nancy and enjoy your trip to Peru.

cheers
Robin

4

## On 12/13/17 12:28 PM, Lawrence Krauss wrote: (cont.)

Lawrence M. Krauss Director, The Origins Project at ASU Co-Director, Cosmology =nitiative Foundation =rofessor School of Earth & Space Exploration and Physics Department Arizona State Universi P.O. Box 871404, Tempe, AZ 85287-1404 Research Office: = Assistant (Jessica): Origins Office (Cynthia):

origins.asu.edu

<image002.png>

Lawrence M. =rauss
Director, The Origins Project at ASU
Co-Director, Cosmology Initiative
Foundation =rofessor
School =f Earth & Space Exploration and Physics =epartment
Arizona State Universi , P.O. Box =71404, Tempe, AZ 85287-1404
Research Office: I Assistant =Jessica):
Origins Office (Cynthia):

origins.asu.edu

=

-Origins Project 10 Year Celebration-
Be a part of something 10 years in the making!
April 5-9th 2018 – Visit for more info <https://www.origins10year.com/>

<image002.png>

Peter Aldhous, PhD
Science reporter | BuzzFeed News
tel: 
cell:

## On 12/13/17 12:28 PM, Lawrence Krauss wrote: (cont.)

peter.aldhous@buzzfeed.com<=r class=""""> @paldhous <https://twitter.com/paldhous>
www.peteraldhous.com <http://www.peteraldhous.com/>