<table><tr><th>From:</th><th>Noam Chomsky &lt;</th></tr><tr><td>Sent:</td><td>Tuesday, November 28, 2017 8:23 PM</td></tr><tr><td>To:</td><td>Jeffrey E.</td></tr><tr><td>Subject:</td><td>Fwd: Transfers to/for Noam</td></tr></table>

Key Information:

*   **From:** Noam Chomsky
*   **Date:** Tue, Nov 28, 2017 at 1:21 PM
*   **Subject:** Re: Transfers to/for Noam
*   **To:** Deborah Pechet Quinan
*   **Cc:** Valeria Chomsky, Gene Landy, Richard Kahn

=div dir="Itr">We've been trying to figure out the matter of the dist=ibutions from the Marital Trust. We received no notice of this from Max. 1= seems, from what you say here, that the distributions would have gone dir=ctly to the Treasury, for taxes. In order to keep our records straig=t, we contacted Nick almost 3 weeks ago to find out what the full tax bill=was and how much we actually paid, assuming that the distribution must hav= paid the rest. But we have not heard from him.

<=iv>So at the moment it's unclear just what happened with these distrib=tions from the Marital Trust.

On the distribution= to the grandchildren, at least in 2016 I have no record of even being con=ulted, and have no record of any formal authorization for earlier years4=iv>

In case I hadn't made it clear before, yes, ple=se do keep Richard Kahn copied.

Noam

On Thu, Nov 9, 2017 at 2:=4 PM, Deborah Pechet Quinan <██████████ <mailto:██████████> wrote:

Dear Noam,<=span>

The distributions that we=e made for taxes in 2015 and 2016 were to pay your and Valeria's e=timated income taxes for tax year 2015. These were the distributions that I succeeded in getting Max to agree to make from the Marital Trusts a= I was disturbed at the time, and still am, by the fact that distributions=for your and Valeria's lifestyle and all income tax payments were =eing made from your IRA and subjected to a much high level of taxation than necessary, thus unnecessarily running d=wn the IRA funds, considering that your funds in the Marital Trusts were a=ailable for your needs.

With regard to the gifts =o your children and grandchildren, according to Max's summary dist=ibutions to your Charitable Gift Fund, to your children, to your grandchildren, and to the Chomsky Grandchildren's Trust were made =rom January 12, 2010 through January 13, 2016. Since you are t=e only beneficiary of the Marital Trusts (this is a legal requirement) the=e would be considered gifts from you, and as such you would have had to have given Max permission or direction to make these=distributions.

I hope this is helpful.=C2* Noam do you want me to keep Richard Kahn copied on our correspondenc=? You would be waiving attorney client privilege as we have discusse= and I am concerned that he and I will be working inefficiently if we are b=th not copied on all emails regarding your and Valeria's financial=affairs. Please let me know as I think his input is helpful. l=am not copying him on replies to you where you have not copied him on your initial email to me, hence my question.</=>

I look forward to hearing=from you.

Best,

Deborah

___________________________________________________=C2
Deborah Pechet Quinan, Esq. LL.M.
Shareholder
Assistant - Jayne Mahoney: █████████████████████████>
Office:██████████████████████████████████████████████████████████
e-mail:████████████████████████████> = www.riw.com <http://www.riw.co=/> | BIO
<http://www.riw.c=m/attorney/deborah-pechet-quinan/>

From
Sent: Thursday, November 09, 2017 4:10 PM
To: Deborah Pechet Quinan
Cc: Valeria Chomsky; Gene Landy

Subject: Fwd: Transfers to/for Noam

=div>

Please do send hard copies to us, and either fax or =ard copies to Richard Kahn, depending on his preference.

I looked over what Max sent. It is of no use.=C24> The distributions that allegedly went to me are for taxes, but I hav= no record of this and have no idea what it means. Taxes for what?=C24> For which accounts? Did that relieve taxes that I was supposed to pay? If so, how? With no details given, this d=esn't tell me anything useful. As for distribution to grandchild=en's trusts, that was in 2014. I don't recall giving authorisation then.

- Surrounding text (context): looked over what Max sent; distributions allegedly to the recipient are for taxes but no record or details (which taxes/accounts/how it relieved taxes unknown); distribution to grandchildren’s trusts noted as 2014 and authorization not recalled. Starts “Dear [recipients].”

- Image: email screenshot showing a forwarded message header and heavy redactions.

- Visible header fields:
  - Indicator: “---------- Forwarded message ----------”
  - From: [redacted]
  - Date: Thu, Nov 9, 2017 at 12:36 PM
  - Subject: RE: Transfers to/for [redacted]
  - To: [redacted] (multiple recipients; addresses partially redacted / shown as mailto links)

- Other details:
  - Top of image shows a single-line greeting/name: “[redacted]”
  - Multiple long black redaction blocks obscure sender/recipient addresses and additional lines of the message.

Dear Noam and Valeria,

## <=>:

Further to my note to you=of yesterday, below, please let me know if you would like my office to send you hard or fax copies of Max's latest information and if you=would like me to forward to Richard. Please also let me know if all =f the distributions to the children and grandchildren over the years were =ade with Noam's agreement.

<=>:

I look forward to your re=ponses to my emails over the course of this week which raised various issu=s.

</=>

I hope you are both well.=/span>

</=>

Best,

Deborah<=u>

</=>

___________________________________=C2

## <=>: (cont.)

Deborah Pechet Quinan, Esq. LL.M.
Shareholder
Chair, Trusts & Estates Group<=pan style="font-size:10.5pt;font-family:"Calibri","sans-s=rif";color:black">
<https://maps.google.com/?q=255+State+Street,+7th+Floor%C2%A0%7=%C2%A0Boston,+MA+02109&entry=g
mail&source=g> |<=a> Boston, MA 02109
<https://maps.google.com=?q=255+State+Street,+7th+Floor%C2%A0%7C%C2%A0Boston,+MA+02109&entry=3Dgmail&
source=g>

Direct:  > =C2  | <https://maps.google.com/?q=255+State+Street,+7th+Floor%C2%A0%7C+%3Chttps://maps.google.com/?q%3D2=5%2BState%2BStreet,%2B7th%2BFloor%25C2%25A0%257C%25C2%25A0Boston,%2BMA%2B0=109%26entry%3Dgmail%26source%3Dg%3E%C2%A0Boston,%0D+MA+02109+%3Chttps://ma=s.google.com/?q%3D255%2BState%2BStreet,%2B7th%2BFloor%25C2%25A0%257C%25C2%25A0Boston,%2BMA%2B02109%26entry%3Dgmail%26source%3Dg%3E&entry=gmail&=mp;source=g> =A0Cell: 617.832.5726 <tel:(617)%20832-5726> </=pan>
Assistant - Jayne Mahoney: 
Direct:  > <=pan style="font-size:11.0pt;font-family:"Calibri","sans-s=rif";color:#1f497d"> |<=pan style="font-size:11.0pt;font-family:"Calibri","sans-s=ref";color:#1f497d"> 
Direct:  > <=pan style="font-size:11.0pt;font-family:"Calibri","sans-s=ref";color:#1f497d"> 
e-mail:  = www.riw.com <http://www.riw.co=/> | BIO <http://www.riw.c=m/attorney/deborah-pechet-quinan/>

## <=>

From: Deborah =echet Quinan
Sent: Wednesday, November 08, 2017 5:03 PM
To: Noam Chomsky; | <mailto
Subject: Fwd: Transfers to/for Noam

Dear Noam and Valeria,

Were you able to open and access the secure email fr=m Max? If not would you like me to have the contents faxed to you tomorrow=

Please also let me know if you would like my office =o fax the contents to Richard.

The information is quite interesting. It looks as th=ugh much more in distributions was made to your children and grandchildren=from the marital trusts than to you and I wonder whether this was done with your agreement?

I am home sick today but will be able to coordinate =or you tomorrow when I hope to be back in the office.

Best,

Deborah

<=p>

Sent from my iPhone. Please excuse brevity and typos=

Begin forwarded message:

## <=> (cont.)

| Field | Extracted text |
|---|---|
| From | "Pr=ofpoint Essentials on behalf of" [REDACTED] |
| Date | November 7, 2017 at 5:05:14 PM EST |
| To | [REDACTED] (angle-bracketed email in image) |
| Subject | Transfers to/for Noam |
| Reply-To | [REDACTED] <mailto:do-not-...> |
| Other visible tokens | ">=<r>" and "=>=<u>" visible near header lines |

Encrypted=Message Received:

Transfers to/for Noam

You have received an encrypted email from:

© Proofpoint Inc. 2017 A=l Rights Reserved.

NOTICE: This email with its attachments, if any, is =ntended solely for permitted use by authorized recipients. If you are not =n authorized recipient of this email, your retention, transmission, disclo=ure, or use of this email is prohibited. If you received this email in error, please notify the sender and delete t=is email and its attachments from your devices and systems.

NOTICE: This email with its attachments, if any, is intended solely for per=itted use by authorized recipients. If you are not an authorized recipient=of this email, your retention, transmission, disclosure, or use of this em=il is prohibited. If you received this email in error, please notify the sender and delete this email and it= attachments from your devices and systems.

## <=> (cont.)