The image shows an email thread between bellaklein and Karyna Shuliak. The subject is "Re: postmates." Karyna mentions using the application for food delivery, sometimes for 9 East 71st. Bella inquires if 9 east is for guests or personal use. Contact information is provided for both parties. The emails were sent from iPhones.

On Nov 13, 2014, at 10:05 AM, bellaklein <

<mailto:

>> wrote:

Hi Karyna,

Is the below charges food deliveries or subscription?

<table><tr><th>10/25/2014</th><th>POSTMATES.COM &lt;http://postmates.com/&gt;</th><th>8008826106 CA</th><th>254.99</th><th>subscription</th></tr><tr><td>10/24/2014</td><td>POSTMATES.COM &lt;http://postmates.com/&gt;</td><td>8008826106 CA</td><td>176.64</td><td>subscription</td></tr></table>

Thank you,

Bella

<mailto
Tel: